Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Surviving the Billionaire Wars's avatar

It helps to use accurate language, not the words they apply to things.

We haven't been "locked down", we've been locked up, imprisoned, incarcerated.

Also, Russia didn't "just roll through Ukraine" in a vacuum. The west has been provoking Russia since Clinton & Putin took office.

When the USSR broke up, Yeltsin "gave away" to Ukraine significant portions of Russia. The people who inhabited those areas, since the US backed coup overthrew the Ukraine government & installed a puppet government in 2014, have been targeted by neo-nazis funded & trained by US tax dollars. Those neo-nazis have been embedded into the Nato-trained military. They have shelled the Donbass region with artillery, tortured & murdered Russians. They cut off Crimea from its natural water (the dam only just blown up in recent weeks).

The US & Nato pushed Russia too far. Evidence has emerged that they were planning a direct attack on Russia, to begin on March 18.

Expand full comment
SCA's avatar

Yes, most of this is true.

It's true because intellect cannot permanently master the animal nature. But what I think you miss is that the Lord quoted in the passage from Samuel is a human creation. "Hey--I'm the ruler you want! And you'll be sorry if you choose someone else..." Still a ruler; still a demand for a terrible conformity. The holy document of my people makes genocide legitimate when God says it's OK; makes the killing of those who step out of line legitimate; makes women subordinate and captive to bad marriages; was the basis of the witch-persecution craze that poisoned Europe and, briefly, America. The regulation of every detail of daily life, and the transgression of any which makes you a sinner--that's what we're seeing exactly right now, just from secular and not religious authorities.

The God of the Bible--or more accurately Torah--is a tribal god evolved in conception to be the only God. It always amazed me how so many people who claim to be followers of Christ are actually in temperament Old Testament Christians with the rigidity and cruelty that reflects.

It's my belief that our innate yearning towards a Higher Authority both enables us to sense the reality of the Unknowable Creator and leads us too often to envision that Creator in our own image and creates the uncontrollable desire to have tangible power like that.

We shouldn't want a theocracy. The people were required to tithe tangible goods to the Temple, weren't they? To offer burnt sacrifices of killed living creatures to please the nostrils of an incorporeal being? If we think the Scriptures are true, how can we choose which laws are outdated and which are eternal?

The hard lesson that generations always must relearn is that the work of establishing, maintaining and perpetuating Justice is never done. The Founders of this nation were astonishingly, astoundingly wise men in their vision, despite their human frailties. It's the Enlightenment that molded them.

But every system degrades over time and needs to be refreshed. The rationalism of Western European intellectualism became postmodernist bullshit. It's no accident that these idiot children today are pulling down statues of Jefferson and Washington, because they're incapable of separating, as it were, the divine from the profane.

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts